Good Followership: Not Everyone Wants to Be a Leader
-By Rudy Pauwels

Many years ago, Terrie said something to me that has stayed with me ever since:
“A good follower is as important as a good leader.”
At the time, I didn't give those words as much thought as I do today. But the more I look back at my own life and the different positions I've held, the more I understand the importance of good followership. It has also made me question why we place so much importance on becoming a leader, while being a good follower is rarely celebrated as an achievement in itself.
I'm 62 now. During my military service as a reserve officer, my 21 years in the Belgian Gendarmerie and approximately 20 years as an entrepreneur, I've experienced both leadership and followership. There were times when I had to make decisions that affected other people and times when I had to follow decisions made by someone else. During more than 20 years beside Terrie, I also had the opportunity to observe leadership in a completely different business environment.
Looking back at those experiences, I wonder whether we have created a society where becoming a leader is almost seen as the ultimate measure of professional success.
But what about those who don't want to become leaders? Does that make them any less ambitious?
Why Is Good Followership Undervalued?
If you tell someone they are a natural leader, they will probably take it as a compliment. But what would happen if you told that same person they are a natural follower?
I doubt many people would take it as a compliment.
Why is that? Both roles are necessary, yet we seem to attach a completely different value to them. We associate leadership with intelligence, confidence, courage and success, while followership is often associated with obedience, dependence and a lack of initiative.
From my own experience, a good follower needs many of the same qualities as a good leader. They need to be able to think independently, communicate, make decisions, accept responsibility and recognise when something is going wrong. They also need the courage to speak up when they believe their leader is making a mistake.
Following someone doesn't mean handing over your ability to think. Neither does it mean that you are less intelligent or less capable than the person you are following.
Perhaps one of the biggest problems with good followership is not the role itself, but the image we have created around it.
What If Someone Simply Doesn't Want to Be the Boss?
Imagine an employee who has worked for a company for fifteen years. They are excellent at their job, have a great deal of experience, are respected by their colleagues and are someone the company can always rely on.
One day, management offers them a promotion. They are given the opportunity to manage a team of people doing the same work they have been doing for years. But they turn it down.
How would management react? Would they respect that decision, or would they question the employee's ambition and commitment to the company?
Perhaps that person genuinely enjoys what they do. Perhaps they have no interest in managing people, dealing with internal politics or spending a large part of their day attending meetings. They may simply want to continue doing the work that gives them satisfaction.
During my years in the police and later in business, I encountered people with different ambitions. Some wanted more authority and wanted to lead others, while others were more interested in becoming better at what they were already doing.
I don't believe one ambition is necessarily greater than the other. There is a difference between wanting to become better at something and wanting to become responsible for the people doing it.
Good followership should not be considered a temporary stage in someone's career before they become a leader. For some people, it may be exactly where they want to be.
Are We Promoting People Away From What They Do Best?
When someone is an outstanding salesperson, the next logical step often seems to be making that person a sales manager. When someone is an excellent technician, we may eventually put them in charge of other technicians.
But being exceptionally good at a particular job doesn't automatically mean someone will be good at managing people doing that job. The skills are different, the responsibilities are different, and the satisfaction someone gets from their work may also be completely different.
A person who enjoyed meeting customers, building relationships and closing sales may suddenly find themselves spending most of their time managing people, preparing reports and attending meetings.
The company may have lost an excellent salesperson without necessarily gaining an excellent sales manager.
What makes this even more difficult is that some people may accept a promotion simply because they feel they are expected to. They may be concerned that turning it down will affect their future within the company or that management will no longer see them as ambitious.
I'm not suggesting that promoting people is wrong. For many people, moving into leadership is exactly what they want. What I'm questioning is why we sometimes treat it as the only natural way forward.
Isn't there something contradictory about a company needing good followers to succeed, yet encouraging its best followers to stop being followers?
Being a Leader and a Follower at the Same Time
My military experience taught me something that I believe is just as relevant in business today.
An officer may be responsible for leading a group of people, but that same officer is also following the direction of someone above them. An NCO may be leading soldiers while following the instructions of an officer.
Being a leader doesn't suddenly release you from the responsibility of being a good follower.
I experienced something similar during my years in the Gendarmerie. Having a certain rank or position didn't mean that I would always know more than the people around me. Experience, knowledge and the circumstances of a particular situation could make someone else's judgment extremely valuable.
Later, as a business owner, I was responsible for making decisions, but that didn't mean I always had the best answer. There were situations where listening to someone else was far more valuable than insisting on my own opinion.
I think this is where leadership and followership become particularly interesting. We tend to describe leaders and followers as two different kinds of people, yet in reality we move between those roles throughout our lives, sometimes several times during the same day.
Even the CEO of a large company may need to follow the advice of someone several levels below them in the organisation. That person may have knowledge and experience the CEO doesn't have.
Perhaps one of the most important qualities we can develop is knowing when to lead and when to follow, regardless of our position within an organisation.
Should Businesses Reward Good Followership?
Another question I have is how companies financially reward their employees.
In many organisations, earning a significantly higher salary means moving into management. An experienced employee may eventually reach a point where there is very little opportunity to increase their income without taking on a management position.
What message does that send to the people who want to remain specialists in their field?
Consider someone who has spent twenty years developing their knowledge and skills. Their experience may save the company considerable amounts of money, help solve difficult problems and prevent costly mistakes.
Should their earning potential be limited simply because they don't want to manage other people?
Some organisations have recognised this by creating separate career paths for specialists and managers. I find that an interesting approach because it allows people to grow professionally without forcing them into positions that may not suit them.
But financial reward is only part of it. Recognition, respect and opportunities to continue learning are equally important. People need to feel that their contribution is valued, even if they have no desire to move into management.
Surely the value someone brings to an organisation should also be measured by their contribution, rather than simply by the number of people reporting to them.
Good Followership and the Ability to Lead Yourself
One thing I learned as a business owner is how important it is to have people who can think and act for themselves.
When you employ someone, you cannot always be there to tell them what to do. Customers will have questions, unexpected problems will arise and decisions sometimes need to be made immediately.
Imagine owning a shop and leaving an employee in charge for a few days. A customer comes in with a problem that hasn't been covered by any of the instructions you gave that employee.
Would you prefer them to tell the customer to come back when you return, or would you prefer them to use their own judgment and try to find a reasonable solution within their responsibilities?
An employee who understands the direction of the business, takes responsibility and uses their own judgment can be extremely valuable.
Would I describe that person as a leader or a follower?
Perhaps they are both.
They are following the direction of the business while taking responsibility for leading themselves. They don't necessarily need a management position or a team reporting to them to demonstrate leadership qualities.
This is another reason why I believe good followership deserves far more recognition. A good follower isn't simply someone who carries out instructions. It is someone who understands the purpose behind those instructions and knows how to act when there is nobody around to give them further direction.
Are We Investing Enough in Good Followership?
There are countless books, seminars, courses and professional development programmes dedicated to leadership. Companies invest considerable amounts of money in identifying and developing their future leaders.
I understand why, but I wonder how many organisations invest specifically in developing good followers.
Do we teach employees how to respectfully challenge a decision? Do we encourage them to think independently, take responsibility and recognise when they need to speak up? Do we help them understand the difference between supporting a leader and blindly agreeing with one?
These are skills that can be developed, just as leadership skills can be developed.
I also wonder how many people who attend leadership courses are encouraged to reflect on their own abilities as followers. After all, someone who struggles to accept another person's direction, listen to advice or acknowledge that someone else knows better may also struggle when they become responsible for leading others.
Considering that most people spend a significant part of their working lives following someone else's direction, wouldn't it make sense to give good followership a more important place in professional development?
We need good leaders, but even the most capable leader will struggle without people who know how to follow well.
Perhaps We Need to Rethink Ambition
The older I get, the more I question some of the ways we measure success.
A higher position, a bigger salary, a more impressive title and having more people reporting to you are all things that society often associates with professional achievement.
But what about the person who enjoys going to work every morning, takes pride in what they do, continues learning and makes a genuine contribution to the people around them?
What if that person has no desire to become the boss?
Ambition can also mean becoming exceptionally good at something. It can mean sharing your knowledge with others, improving the way things are done and continuing to learn throughout your working life. None of those things necessarily requires a management position.
I keep coming back to what Terrie told me all those years ago. If a good follower really is as important as a good leader, then we should recognise good followership as an achievement in its own right, rather than simply a stage in someone's journey towards leadership.
Imagine asking an employee where they see themselves in five years and receiving the following answer:
“Doing what I'm doing today, but doing it even better.”
Would you be disappointed by that answer?
Perhaps how we respond says more about our own definition of success than it does about that person's ambition.
And if everyone aspires to become a leader, who aspires to become an exceptionally good follower?
Rudy Pauwels
Continuing the ideas and legacy of Terrie Anderson.
Comments