top of page
  • Black Facebook Icon

A Good Follower Doesn’t Always Agree With the Leader By Rudy Pauwels

Rudy pauwels
Oct 15
6 min read
“Two people discussing a disagreement, illustrating good followership and the courage to tell a leader, ‘I think you’re wrong.’”

My late wife, Terrie Anderson, once said something to me that has stayed with me for many years: “A good follower is as important as a good leader.” It sounded quite simple when she said it, but over the years I started to understand there was much more behind it. I wrote recently about why I think we undervalue good followership, particularly because the word follower itself has somehow become a negative word in business. We want to be leaders, develop leaders and be seen as leaders, but very few people would proudly put “good follower” on their LinkedIn profile.


Since writing that article, I’ve been thinking about another part of this. What actually makes somebody a good follower? Surely it can’t simply mean being good at following instructions or agreeing with the person above you. In fact, I think one of the most important qualities of a good follower appears at exactly the moment when they don’t agree with their leader.


There comes a time in almost every working relationship when you believe the person above you is getting something wrong. Maybe you know something they don’t know. Maybe you can see a problem developing because you’re closer to the customer, the product or the people doing the actual work. Or maybe you simply look at the same information and come to a different conclusion. That’s when you have a choice. You can keep your mouth shut and do what you’re told, or you can have the courage to say, respectfully, “I think you’re wrong.”


I don’t consider myself a leadership expert and I don’t want these articles to sound as though I’m trying to become one. I’m 62 years old and most of what I’m writing comes from things I’ve experienced and observed throughout my own life. I served in the military and the Belgian Gendarmerie, later went into business and employed people myself, and I spent more than 20 years beside Terrie watching her work at senior levels in technology and cybersecurity. I’ve seen good leaders and bad leaders, good employees and difficult ones, and I’ve also seen situations where people knew something wasn’t right but decided it was easier to say nothing.


And I can understand why. Speaking up can be uncomfortable, particularly when the person on the other side of the table has considerably more power than you do. You might have a mortgage, children, bills to pay and a career you don’t particularly want to put at risk. It’s very easy for somebody senior to say, “I want my people to challenge me,” but it’s quite another thing to create an environment where people actually believe they can do it without paying a price afterwards.


That’s the part that interests me.

Do leaders really want to be challenged?

I’ve heard variations of the same sentences many times in business: “My door is always open.” “I want honest feedback.” “I don’t want yes-people around me.” Most leaders probably genuinely mean it when they say those things. But it’s easy to welcome disagreement when the disagreement doesn’t really matter. The real test comes when somebody challenges a decision that you strongly believe is right.


Imagine you’ve spent weeks working on something. You’ve discussed it with senior management, you’ve put your reputation behind it and you’re ready to go. Then somebody further down the organisation says, “I don’t think we should do this.” How do you react? Do you become defensive? Do you immediately start explaining why they’re wrong? Do you see them differently afterwards? Or do you stop for a moment and genuinely ask yourself, What are they seeing that I’m not seeing?


I think that’s a much more useful test of leadership than asking a leader whether they encourage people to speak up. Almost everybody is going to answer yes to that question. Instead, I’d ask: Think about the last time somebody who worked for you told you that you were wrong. What did you actually do next?


Maybe the person challenging you was wrong. That’s perfectly possible too. Good followership doesn’t mean the follower is automatically right and the leader is wrong. But I would still rather have people around me who are prepared to think independently than people who work out what I want to hear and give me exactly that.


There is also something about loyalty here that I think we sometimes misunderstand. We tend to associate loyalty with agreement and support, but I’m not sure that’s always true. Sometimes the person who is most loyal to you, or most committed to the business, may be the person prepared to have an uncomfortable conversation with you. If I’m about to make a serious mistake in my own business, I don’t want somebody sitting across from me thinking, Rudy has got this completely wrong, but he’s the boss so I’ll keep quiet. I’d much rather hear, “Rudy, I think you’re making a mistake here, and this is why.”

That doesn’t mean I have to agree with them. It means I should listen.


There is another side to it

This is where good followership becomes more complicated, because I don’t think constantly challenging the person above you makes you a good follower either. At some point a decision has to be made. You may have raised your concerns, explained your reasoning and had a proper opportunity to be heard. The leader may have listened carefully and still decided to go in another direction.

What happens then?


Assuming we’re talking about an ethical and legitimate decision, I think there comes a point when a good follower needs to be able to say, “I still don’t agree with the decision, but you’ve heard me, you’ve made the decision and I’ll support it.” That’s not weakness and it isn’t blind obedience. Somebody ultimately has to carry responsibility for making the decision, and an organisation where every decision is debated forever isn’t going to get very far.


My military experience probably influences the way I look at this. In the military, you can see very clearly that being a leader and being a follower are not opposites. A non-commissioned officer may be following the direction of the officer above while at exactly the same time leading the soldiers below. An officer may have command responsibility but still rely heavily on the experience and judgment of people around them. There are times to question, times to advise, times to make your case and also times when the decision has been made and everybody needs to move in the same direction.


Business isn’t the military, of course, but I think there is something useful in that principle. A manager leads a team while following the direction of an executive. That executive may lead hundreds or even thousands of people, yet when a serious technical, legal or cybersecurity issue arises, they may need to follow the advice of somebody who understands that subject far better than they do. Within a single day the same person can lead in one situation and follow in another.


That’s why I’m beginning to wonder whether we put too much importance on the labels leader and follower. Perhaps they aren’t two different types of people at all. Perhaps what matters more is whether somebody has the judgment to understand when to lead, when to follow, when to challenge and when to support.


Something I learned from watching Terrie

I had the privilege of watching Terrie work for more than 20 years. I saw her career from a very different perspective than most of the people who worked with her because I saw what happened after the meetings and phone calls were finished. We talked about people, companies, decisions, things that had gone well and things that had gone completely wrong. Terrie worked across different countries and cultures and with people at many different levels of organisations, and I learned a great deal simply by listening to her.


Looking back now, I don’t think the people a strong leader values most are necessarily the people who agree with them most often. I think they’re the people whose judgment they learn to trust. They don’t argue simply for the sake of arguing and they don’t need to have an opinion about absolutely everything. But when they do say, “Hang on, I don’t think this is right,” you stop and listen because you know there is probably a reason they’re saying it.

That relationship requires something from both people. The follower needs enough courage to be honest, even when honesty is uncomfortable. The leader needs enough confidence to hear disagreement without automatically treating it as disloyalty or disrespect. And both of them need enough humility to accept the possibility that they could be wrong.


Perhaps that is where good leadership and good followership actually meet.


So I’d like to finish with the question I’ve been thinking about since our recent discussion about followership. Think about the last person who worked for you who was prepared to tell you that you were wrong. What happened to that person afterwards? Did they still feel comfortable challenging you the next time? Did you still ask for their opinion? Did you perhaps eventually discover that they were right?


Because maybe the real test of a leader isn’t whether they say they welcome disagreement. It’s what happens to people after they disagree.


And maybe the real test of a good follower isn’t simply whether they know how to follow. It’s whether they have the judgment to know when they shouldn’t.

Rudy Pauwels

Comments


© 2026 created  by Rudy Pauwels for Terrie Anderson

  • Follow Terrie Anderson books on Facebook
  • White Instagram Icon
bottom of page